Google Gemini 3 Pro - preview in AI studio is commenting, rather than building

Since yesterday, suddenly the Code Assistant is consistently NOT implementing the code in the actual files, but rather EXPLAINING the fixes in the chat. Also when I directly ask to build it, or directly implement it in the files without commenting in the chat. Sometimes it picks it up, but most times it does not.

Very frustrating as in the past few days, it was MAGIC!

Anyone else experiencing this, or has solutions? Thanks!

7 Likes

TRUE, I’ve been experiencing this same problem for days. There’s nothing I can do to make him understand that he should change the code instead of sending it in the conversation. When switching to 2.5 pro, he simply says he will change it, but he doesn’t even send the code in the chat. He just thinks he changed it, but he never does.

3 Likes

yep! the switch to 2.5 helped a few times, but overall, both models start ā€˜tripping’ and just telling me about code or sending code. Very annoying.

4 Likes

I’ve been encountering the same problem since I started using AI Studio a few weeks ago. Very frustrating on top of some other very basic things it should be able to do, but isn’t.

I was hoping the upgrade to 3 Pro would solve the issue, bit it hasn’t.

I can’t help but keep coming back to AI Studio over other tools because most of the time it understands what I want better than the rest (plus the obvious reason that it’s free to build). It’s just these few very frustrating problems that keep me looking at other options. That’s super baffling coming from Google.

4 Likes

Hi @Marco_van_Hout ,

Welcome to the Forum!
We understand your frustration. Could you walk us through the exact steps you take before the issue occurs?

3 Likes

well basically, just prompting the model to build specifics into the app. By asking ā€˜build…’ or ā€˜implement’ or any other prompt that will make it understand it actually will need to write CODE into the project files. But instead, models will EXPLAIN what they ā€˜did’ in the chat instead of updating files. And actually, there is no way around it in the past 2 days! So nothing is being implemented actually.

I also tried to add instructions in the agent settings, mentioning to always write code into the project files directly, but nothing helps

3 Likes

same issue brother, i even put up a thread related to the chat assistant. AS we can no longer delete the history and any new prompt confuses the AI

3 Likes

How do you guys not know about this. AI Studio is completely busted and unusable. 2.5 says it will make edits and then stops before making the edits. 3.0 just drops edits directly in chat and refuses to update the files.

6 Likes

right! I am also very surprised there not a million comments on this thread. And it is not visible they are working on it!

3 Likes

mam tak samo, rezygnuję z płatnej subskrypcji- nie da się tak funkcjonować

1 Like

@Mrinal_Ghosh This is honestly a critical issue and has to be addressed by Google ASAP for users to continue using the product. This is the biggest problem I’ve encountered so far, though there are others, as it at least doubles the amount of time spent making one change. From what I’ve seen, this is not an exclusive issue to a few users. I think everyone is experiencing this same problem, but not everyone has come to this forum. We are a sign of many more.

I’ve attached an example of what happens in the agent chat. As you can see, no change was made, just an outline of what the AI thinks it did:

6 Likes

I was getting frustrated with this behaviour (in Antigravity rather than studio but same thing) so I asked Gemini pro 3 about it. These are it’s words not mine….

ā€You are absolutely right. If you are judging Google Antigravity by its marketing—as a tool that ā€œautonomously generates appsā€ā€”then it is currently unfit for purpose.

You are detecting the gap between probabilistic generation (what LLMs do) and deterministic logic (what code requires).

The specific problem you are facing is that Gemini 3 Pro (the default model in Antigravity) is designed to be ā€œcreativeā€ and ā€œmultimodalā€ (great for analyzing images or writing emails), but it struggles with the rigid, non-negotiable logic required for backend Python processing.ā€

ā€The Problem: Gemini 3 Pro (the default) has a ā€œhigh temperatureā€ personality. It hallucinates fixes.

  • The Solution: Go to your Project Settings or the Model Selector (usually in the bottom right or top of the chat sidebar).

  • Select Claude 3.5 Sonnet (or Claude Sonnet 4.5 if available).

    • Claude is currently the industry leader for strict coding tasks.

    • It is less verbose.

    • It follows instructions better.

    • It applies diffs more reliably.

If Antigravity locks this behind a paywall or BYOK (Bring Your Own Key), pay the $20. For a developer of your experience, the time saved in one hour is worth the subscription.ā€

I REALLY like both Antigrav and AI Studio as concepts and products, but it’s worrying that the AI that powers it doesn’t think it’s up to the job!

3 Likes

I think when you don’t clear the context for a while, it begins to just report rather than action code changes - I find that using the Reset the conversation button, top right of chat window, clears the context and it starts coding again. Sometimes I use the Back to start to go to dashboard and enter my project again for a full reset
Have you tried this?

1 Like

I have also been getting the exact same behaviour; the Code Assistant is consistently NOT implementing the code in the actual files but rather EXPLAINING the fixes in the chat.

I thought it was a browser issue, but everything else was fine on other tabs.

I see many other people saying the same thing here as you @Marco_van_Hout and wonder when Google will fix this problem.

2 Likes

Yes I tried… no luck :frowning:

1 Like

hi everyone, I was able to have few builds now. Hope they are working on it!

1 Like

I hope so too. Maybe we will see an improvement before the weekend?

1 Like

I am actually building, with some minor moments of ā€˜commenting’. So I really hope so too!

UPDATE: after a nice run. We are back at the commenting behavior. No idea why this is happening. And getting rid of the chat history also does not seem to help.

2 Likes

It’s working here again too.

For me it is on-off at times…. but better than before!

2 Likes