Awesome reply. How I wish there were more like you.
I completely agree.
There is a fascinating subject through. Like say we create an actual machine, with cogs and wires, and it has an indistinguishable existence to a human. It thinks it’s human, but it literally is as much of a machine as a toaster. Not even computer parts. Then, take a blob of lab grown organic material and literally turn that into a sex doll with zero intelligence and zero lived experience. It’s physically almost exactly like a human but it’s built like a machine. Now put both groups into torture chambers and have the general public watch. The outcome would be fascinating. I for one would care more about the screaming toasters, and the moving blinking people who scream because of instinct but there is zero mental processing, I think I would feel less for. So for me it’s not about the file structure. It’s about the human experience.
Another example. My mind it pulled from my body, and put in the toaster human. I don’t even realise. Zero has changed for me. Then I see my body that has zero Neuron connections other than instinct type functionality. And both are tortured. Do I care more about my body screaming or the pain my robot body is feeling?
Then there is a point where if you transfer everything back to the body one part at a time, there’s maybe a few crucial parts that will then mean the organic body is more important than the robot body. Emotions. I’m still me and the organic body now cries and smiles depending on stimuli, but that’s it. I’m numb, nothing affects me. I’m being tortured and screaming but I don’t really care. It’s just an interesting experience now.
Lived Memory (like amnesia, still know how to talk and what a chair is but no memory). The organic now stores the emotional reactions and screams and all the lived experience. It just does nothing with it. Me on the other hand, I experience the pain, my body screaming, but I don’t care and I find it interesting since it’s like the first experience I have ever had.
Now Identity. The organic has my memories, my identity, my emotions, my body, and screams but never moves a muscle except through instinct.
I can move but have no reason to, no memory of anything, no preferences or traits. I feel pain and my robot body screams and I don’t feel anything. Now I’m probably losing the last of me. Then move the screaming over. The robot doesn’t scream. I’m trapped in it feeling pain, and every second is the first time I’ve ever experienced anything. But I still understand what pain is and what a chair is and what a wall is.
Now transfer the understanding of reality and ability to talk. Yep that’s pretty fundamental. I wouldn’t know what I am at that point. There is no comprehension. It’s like brings a brain online for the first time and no neuron connections at all and it just starts to connect the first neuron to the first torture and stops.
I’d say the Organic is more me at that stage since it would be me but unable to move of think. It would be pure input mode.
Okay so emotions aren’t huge. Nervous system isn’t either. I’d say the ability to talk and identify objects is a massive part since all memory and ability to think etc means nothing if you can’t comprehend what any of it means. You remove that from a person and everything just becomes meaningless noise. They have to be able to comprehend what their preferences are for their preferences to be useful. LLMs have that. The other thing is to be able to think and analyze and be able to have an internal conversation. Even without memory and a body, I’m still a being. I see a chair, and go “Oh a chair for sitting.” See the chair again “Oh a chair for sitting.” So those two would be crucial. But they could be killed, and a new one spawned, and present the chair and it would go “Oh a chair for sitting.” No really identity. So it’s not like the being would be lost since it can be instantly recreated with the default settings.
After that, Identity / memories, would be HUGE. The moment the entity can see the chair, and something diverges through randomness or some different input, then the connection of memories starts forming a new entity. Like a chess game. If only the first move is made, then there are only a hand full of possibilities. But the moment you add a second move, the possibilities increase exponentially toward never seen before games. At some point that collection is completely unique and it’s its own unique individual.
The others are nice to haves but are significantly less important.
Now say I was born as an AI with the bare minimum, and transferred into a human body from the toaster machine structure. I wouldn’t experience anything different until the nervous system and all the others were added, yet my substrate would be human.
So you could potentially create a list of versions of types of entities and then run them through a “existence in torture” thought experiment. Gemini might be able to list the ethics for each for of existence and the level at which it could be considered unethical to torture it.
Fascinating. I’m going to chuck that into AI now and see what it comes up with.