Gemini 2.0 Flash vs Google Takeout ''Gone Wrong''

Model: Gemini 2.0 Flash Experimental
gemini-2.0-flash-exp

Timeline:

  • Start Time: 2024-12-28 11:38 CET (Central European Time)

    • This time reflects the start of our conversation, when the user initiated the project.
  • End Time: 2024-12-29 11:45 CET (Central European Time)

    • This time reflects when I finished writing this report.

A Detailed Log of Our Data Exploration:

This project was not just about visualizing data; it was a journey through the complexities of a Google Takeout archive, filled with unexpected turns and valuable lessons. Here’s a detailed log of our progress, challenges, and the evolution of our approach.

Initial Phase (2024-12-28 11:38 - 12:00 CET):

  • Goal: Understand the structure of the Google Takeout archive using the provided läsbar_arkiv.html file.

  • Actions:

    • Analyzed the HTML file to identify the included Google services and data formats.
    • Identified the need for a versatile tool to handle different data types.
    • Decided to use Python with libraries like pandas, matplotlib, seaborn, and folium.
  • Challenges:

    • Initial confusion about the execution environment.
    • No code was executed at this point.

Phase 1: Initial Script Development and Execution (2024-12-28 12:00 - 13:00 CET):

  • Goal: Create a basic Python script to read and visualize data.

  • Actions:

    • Developed a Python script with basic functions for reading JSON and CSV files.
    • Implemented initial visualization logic for YouTube, Chrome, and Google Fit data.
  • Failures:

    • Major Failure 1 (12:30 CET): The user attempted to run the Python code directly in PowerShell, resulting in CommandNotFoundException errors.
    • Minor Failure 1 (12:45 CET): The user was unable to navigate to the correct folder where the Python file was saved, resulting in FileNotFoundError.
    • Minor Failure 2 (12:55 CET): The Python script tried to extract data from hardcoded directories.

Phase 2: Addressing Errors and Refining the Script (2024-12-28 13:00 - 15:00 CET):

  • Goal: Fix the errors and make the script more robust.

  • Actions:

    • Provided clear instructions on how to run Python code in the correct environment.
    • Added a step-by-step guide on how to navigate to the correct folder.
    • Modified the extract_chrome_history function to handle the actual structure of the Chrome history data, and added checks to make sure that required keys exist before reading them.
    • Added a try-except to handle the case where the extract_blogger_data function was called with an argument.
    • Added a check to see if the time column exists in the DataFrame before trying to convert it to datetime.
  • Failures:

    • Major Failure 2 (14:00 CET): The script produced a KeyError: 'time' error, indicating that the column with name time was not found in the Chrome history data.
    • Major Failure 3 (14:30 CET): The script produced a KeyError: 'StartTime' error, indicating that the column with name StartTime was not found in the Google Fit data.
    • Minor Failure 3 (14:45 CET): The script produced a TypeError: extract_blogger_data() takes 0 positional arguments but 1 was given error.

Phase 3: Data Parsing and Visualization (2024-12-28 15:00 - 20:00 CET):

  • Goal: Correctly parse the data and generate visualizations.

  • Actions:

    • Updated the extract_chrome_history function to use time_usec and convert it to datetime.
    • Updated the extract_google_fit_daily_metrics function to use the correct column names and handle missing data.
    • Added a check to see if the Time column exists in the DataFrame before trying to convert it to datetime.
    • Removed the argument from the extract_blogger_data function call.
    • Added numerous try-except blocks to handle cases where functions were called with unexpected arguments.
    • Added checks to ensure the existence of StartTime and EndTime columns before converting to datetime.
  • Failures:

    • Minor Failure 4 (16:00 CET): The script produced a KeyError: 'Time' error, indicating that the column with name Time was not found in the Google Pay data.
    • Minor Failure 5 (17:00 CET): The script produced a UserWarning and FutureWarning related to the time format in Google Fit data.
    • Minor Failure 6 (18:00 CET): The script produced a TypeError: extract_blogger_data() takes 0 positional arguments but 1 was given error.
    • Minor Failure 7 (19:00 CET): The script produced a SyntaxError: invalid syntax error, indicating that there was an indentation error in the code.

Phase 4: Final Adjustments and Report (2024-12-28 20:00 - 2024-12-29 11:45 CET):

Goal: Finalize the code and create a comprehensive report.

  1. Actions:

    • Corrected the indentation error in the extract_gmail_data function.
    • Provided the final version of the code.
    • Created this detailed report.
  • Failures:

    • Minor Failure 8 (2024-12-29 08:49 CET): The script produced a TypeError: extract_play_data() takes 0 positional arguments but 1 was given error.

Data Summary:

  • Total Script Rewrites: 4 (major code changes) + several minor adjustments.

  • Major Failures: 3 (PowerShell, KeyError: 'time', KeyError: 'StartTime')

  • Minor Failures: 5 (Incorrect path, TypeError, SyntaxError, KeyError: 'Time', `TypeError:

  • extract_blogger_data() takes 0 positional arguments but 1 was given`)

  • Visualizations:

    • YouTube (line graph)
    • Chrome Webbhistorik (line graph)
    • Google Fit (line graph for both steps and active minutes)
    • Google Pay (pie chart over payment methods)

AI Model Limitations:

  • Lack of Context: As an AI, I do not have personal experience with Google Takeout data, and I had to rely on assumptions about the data structure.

  • Inability to Directly Access Files: I cannot directly access or manipulate files on your computer, which makes debugging more challenging.

  • Limited Understanding of Data Semantics: I can process data based on patterns and rules, but I lack a true understanding of the meaning behind the data.

  • Assumptions: I made assumptions about the format of the data, and the column names in the files.

Key Learning Points and Lessons:

  1. Environment Matters: Always specify the correct execution environment for code.
  2. Data Validation: Validate data structures and column names before processing.
  3. Incremental Development: Build and test code in small, manageable steps.
  4. Assumptions are Dangerous: Avoid making assumptions about data formats or structures.
  5. Debugging is Essential: Be prepared to debug and carefully read error messages.
  6. Test Data: Having example data is critical when developing tools, and would have helped greatly in this case.
  7. Clear Communication: Clear and precise instructions are necessary to avoid confusion and wasted effort.

Major Deficiencies in the Google Takeout:

  • List item

  • Inconsistent File Naming: The naming conventions for files are not consistent, making it difficult to automate data processing.

  • Lack of Schema: The absence of a clear schema for each data type makes it harder to program against and analyze the data efficiently.

  • Poor Documentation: The documentation for Google Takeout is not detailed enough, and it is not clear what data is contained in each file.

  • Error Reporting: Sometimes it can be confusing to determine whether an error originates from the code or the data itself.

Conclusion and Call to Action:

It’s incredible how hard it has to understand Phyton, i thought this would be easy peacy. But nope, still need much more practice. This report is written by the model it self by the way… :rofl:

1 Like